• This Day in Goodlove History, May 14
• By Jeffery Lee Goodlove
• jefferygoodlove@aol.com
•
• Surnames associated with the name Goodlove have been spelled the following different ways; Cutliff, Cutloaf, Cutlofe, Cutloff, Cutlove, Cutlow, Godlib, Godlof, Godlop, Godlove, Goodfriend, Goodlove, Gotleb, Gotlib, Gotlibowicz, Gotlibs, Gotlieb, Gotlob, Gotlobe, Gotloeb, Gotthilf, Gottlieb, Gottliebova, Gottlob, Gottlober, Gottlow, Gutfrajnd, Gutleben, Gutlove
•
• The Chronology of the Goodlove, Godlove, Gottlob, Gottlober, Gottlieb (Germany) etc., and Allied Families of Battaile, (France), Crawford (Scotland), Harrison (England), Jackson (Ireland), LeClere (France), Lefevre (France), McKinnon (Scotland), Plantagenets (England), Smith (England), Stephenson (England?), Vance (Ireland from Normandy), and Winch (England, traditionally Wales), including correspondence with -George Rogers Clarke, George Washington, and Thomas Jefferson.
•
• The Goodlove/Godlove/Gottlieb families and their connection to the Cohenim/Surname project:
• New Address! http://www.familytreedna.com/public/goodlove/default.aspx
•
• This project is now a daily blog at:
• http://thisdayingoodlovehistory.blogspot.com/
• Goodlove Family History Project Website:
• http://familytreemaker.genealogy.com/users/g/o/o/Jeffery-Goodlove/
•
• Books written about our unique DNA include:
• “Abraham’s Children, Race, Identity, and the DNA of the Chosen People” by Jon Entine.
•
• “ DNA & Tradition, The Genetic Link to the Ancient Hebrews” by Rabbi Yaakov Kleiman, 2004.
“Jacob’s Legacy, A Genetic View of Jewish History” by David B. Goldstein, 2008.
•
• My thanks to Mr. Levin for his outstanding research and website that I use to help us understand the history of our ancestry. Go to http://thisdayinjewishhistory.blogspot.com/ for more information. “For more information about the Weekly Torah Portion or the History of Jewish Civilization go to the Temple Judah Website http://www.templejudah.org/ and open the Adult Education Tab "This Day...In Jewish History " is part of the study program for the Jewish History Study Group in Cedar Rapids, Iowa.
•
A point of clarification. If anybody wants to get to the Torah site, they do not have to go thru Temple Judah. They can use http://DownhomeDavarTorah.blogspot.com and that will take them right to it.
The details for the GOODLOVE FAMILY REUNION were mailed Apr 9, 2011. If you haven't received the information and want to attend, please e-mail 11Goodlovereunion@gmail.com to add your name to the mailing list. RSVP's are needed by May 10.
In a message dated 5/3/2011 3:01:11 P.M. Central Daylight Time, cultural@chicago.mfa.gov.il writes:
Chicago, IL:
Israel Independence Day Party with The Peatot
Saturday, May 14th 2011, 9:00 PM
The Heartland Cafe, 7000 North Glenwood Av, Chicago, 60626
7000 North Glenwood Av,
Chicago, MI 60626
In a message dated 5/4/2011 12:02:09 P.M. Central Daylight Time, JPT@donationnet.net writes:
Dear Jeff,
As one U.S. ally after another falls or finds itself on shaky ground in the Middle East, Israel's leaders must wonder if her long-time friend will come to the rescue if necessary. Perhaps Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has gone back to the dictionary to research the true meaning of the word "ally."
One dictionary defines a political ally as "a country that has agreed officially to give help and support to another one, especially during a war." War could be defined as anything from a border skirmish to an all-out global conflagration. It could be a war on terror—fighting an elusive enemy whose hatred is renowned and whose ultimate aim is the destruction of an entire people.
The countries loyal to the United States are few; but there is one whose steadfastness has not wavered … the State of Israel. The friendship has been of the utmost importance to a succession of presidents since Harry Truman who first endorsed the new nation in 1948. The solidarity between the U.S. and Israel has been tested under past administrations but nothing like the current Obama presidency. The relationship between the two countries both founded on democratic principles and on the Judeo-Christian ethic should be inviolable; it is not.
There are those politicos in Congress who see little or no tactical advantage from a continued association and the $3 billion in military aid to Israel yearly. How foolish! We pour money into Iraq and Afghanistan, the futures of both linked indelibly to the Arab world, not to the United States. Still, there are those in the current administration who bemoan the dollars in military assistance pledged to Israel as being ill-spent, and who fear Muslim retaliation because of U.S.backing for the hated Jewish state.
Those who see Israel as the problem fail to heed the wishes of the majority of the American electorate. Those numbers are not just theoretical; they are substantiated by a Gallup Poll in February 2011 showing that two-thirds of the American people support Israel. Despite the negative media reports aimed at Israel's response to terror attacks by Lebanon and Hamas, support for the tiny nation has increased overall. This would be encouraging if it were not that the Obama Administration and its party pay little heed to what the American people want.
It's important that the U.S. maintains a stable relationship with Israel as the unrest and upheaval continues throughout the Middle East. The strength of the friendship was never more evident than on 9/11. While Israeli citizens halted in mid-stride to honor the victims of the horrendous attack and the prime minister declared a national day of mourning, Palestinians gleefully fired their weapons and danced in the streets. Israel is indisputably pro-American and deserves a clear, unambiguous commitment.
Ties between the Jewish people and the early pilgrims in America are as foundationally strong as the rock on which they stepped ashore in 1620. A group hoping to found a "New Israel" would become highly influential when the colonists began to aspire to freedom. Early founders and presidents of the newly formed republic would express the hope that the children of Israel might one day find rebirth in their homeland—the land God gave to Abraham.
Of late many in the Middle East have cried for democracy while Israel remains a bastion of the very desire of some Arab nations. President John F. Kennedy said of Israel that it carried "the shield of democracy and [honored] the sword of freedom." Not only is she a valued friend and ally, Israel is also a military partner. U.S. soldiers and airmen train alongside the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). Naval combat ships put into port in Haifa, planes are welcome at Israel's airbases, and the U.S. has been given permission to stockpile medical equipment and war matériel in Israel. Marines use a special laser provided by the Israelis and used to aid in targeting specific objects provided by the Israelis.
Israel is the first line of defense against the proliferation of terror worldwide. Maj. Gen. George J. Keegan, Jr. (U.S.A.F. Intelligence) said that the U.S. "owes more to the Israeli intelligence input than it does to any single source of intelligence … [it exceeds] five CIAs."
The $3 billion annually in military aid seems a small price to pay for the edge provided by the ground-breaking discoveries shared with the U.S. for instance, body armor for military vehicles and a "coagulating bandage" used in combat situations (and used to save the life of Rep. Gabrielle Giffords in Tucson, AZ on the day she was targeted by an assassin.) The U.S. and her friends in Israel join together in other, broader efforts: humanitarian aid (earthquake and tsunami relief), commercial endeavors, and scientific discoveries.
As a partner in trade, Israel ranks 20th as one of America's largest buyers of goods and, incidentally, signed the first free trade agreement in U.S. history. The research and development industry in Israel sports such clients as IBM, AOL, Microsoft, and Google. But it's not all one-sided: the Israelis produce high-tech items for the American market as well. The USB flash drive was invented in Israel, as was the microcamera which can be swallowed and tracked through the digestive system. Now, technology architects are working to develop more viable electric vehicles to help reduce the carbon footprint both in Israel and the U.S.
The U.S.-Israel relationship is of indescribable worth. Scientists and inventors in the Jewish nation have readily shared technological advances, innovative designs, and military intelligence with the U.S. The IDF stands ready to assist its counterparts when necessary. We have repaid that generosity with threats of splitting the country asunder and dividing Jerusalem, forcing Israel to give up portions of land necessary to its proper defense, and yet the tiny country surrounded by enemies has remained an ally. But not just an ally—Israel is the only truly reliable and trustworthy friend in the region...and it is time for us to stand up and raise our voices in support.
Dr. Michael Evans
The Latest From HonestReporting
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Financial Times Loses Grip on Reality
Why does the Financial Times consider Hamas to be a credible peace partner? Is it time for a reality check?
May 5, 2011 14:40 by Simon Plosker
The so-called “Arab Spring”, the results of which are still not clear, have prompted many reassessments of the misleading yet previously accepted wisdom that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is the fulcrum at the heart of the Middle East’s troubles.
Even Yasmin Alibhai-Brown who has a long history of Israel bashing has concluded that Israel is not to blame for everything. The Financial Times (click through Google News), however, appears to be living in a different reality. Prompted by the demise of Osama bin Laden, an editorial refers to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict:
The Arab uprising has so shaken up the Middle East that support for revolution implies the urgent resolution of this festering conflict at the heart of regional instability.
When it comes to degrees of extremism, of course, Osama bin Laden represents the most destructive nihilism. This does not mean, however, that Hamas should be favorably compared to Al Qaeda as the FT does:
It is outrageous that Hamas – and a disservice to the Palestinian cause – has acclaimed bin Laden as an “Arab martyr”. Yet it has robustly put down bin Ladenism inside Gaza and pledged to enforce a truce with Israel after joining a national unity government. It must be held to that, but not to the prior recognition of Israel demanded by international mediators.
The preconditions set for Hamas were designed to isolate rather than engage it, a shield against an election result the US and Europe could not stomach. Recognition of Israel should come once its borders are defined at the conclusion of a treaty establishing a Palestinian state, not while Israel is expanding its state on Arab land.
It is inaccurate hyperbole to claim that Israel is “expanding its state on Arab land”. If the FT is so concerned at defining borders, it should make it clear that Israel’s borders have certainly not expanded and any Israeli building that is taking place in the West Bank is doing so within the boundaries of existing settlements and not expanding into new areas.
In addition, does the FT really believe that borders are at the heart of the conflict? Hamas’s entire ideology is based on the non-recognition of any Jewish state in the Middle East irrespective of its borders. Are the lack of defined borders the reason that Hamas is prepared to fire anti-tank missiles at Israeli school buses? Would Hamas really be interested in peace with an Israel that has agreed upon borders?
Compare the FT’s stance on Hamas with an editorial in The Times of London (subscription required) that sees Hamas for what it really is and why Israel and the international community should not be so quick to welcome it into the fold:
In its current form, Hamas is nobody’s partner for peace in the Middle East. An extremist, Islamist, anti-Semitic organisation part-funded by Iran, it holds in its charter the ideal of a Palestinian state from the Jordan to the Mediterranean. It continues to allow rocket attacks on Israel and sponsor suicide assaults. Last September, when Israel and Palestinians began their first direct peace talks in two years, Hamas attempted to disrupt them with an attack that killed four Israelis, one of them a pregnant woman. Stability in the West Bank has come at the price of Fatah’s relentless refusal to tolerate its activities. History does not suggest a peaceable outcome should the jails open and hundreds of militants emerge.
No responsible international government can engage with an administration that includes Hamas without the gravest of reservations.
While The Times gets it, the Financial Times shows scant regard for genuine Israeli security concerns. Hamas is what it is and no amount of criticism of Israeli policy or whitewashing of reality on the part of a newspaper’s editorial will change that. Hamas may be the de facto ruler of Gaza but its essence is still very much that of a vicious terrorist organization that refuses to recognize Israel’s right to exist in the Middle East.
Send your considered comments to the Financial Times – letters.editor@ft.com
This Day…
May 14, 1288: Thirteen Jews in Troyes, France were burned at the stake by the inquisition.[1]
May 14, 1483: Coronation of Charles VIII of France ("Charles l'Affable"). In the second year of his reign, following accusations of usury, the inhabitants of Marseilles, the port city of the recently acquired territory of Provence, attacked the Jewish neighborhoods pillaging them and killing numbers of Jews in 1484 and again in the early months of 1485, leading to an exodus of Jews from the city, especially to Sardinia which became home to about 200 Jewish families of Marseilles. However, King Charles VIII was not inclined to conform to the popular demand of expelling the Jews from Provence. He decreed that all Jews wishing to leave should be allowed to leave Marseilles unharmed on condition they had fulfilled all their engagements with the Christians. The city authorities, on the other hand, were not prepared to let the Jews leave Marseilles with their property and took various measures in order to reduce their emigration, among others they organized an inventory of the Jewish property in Marseilles in 1486. The resulting protests of the Jews assured the royal intervention and a few additional years of protection. The expulsion of the Jews from Spain in 1492 brought new Jewish inhabitants to Marseilles. In 1492 the Jewish community of Marseilles ransomed 118 Jews of Aragon captured by the pirate Bartholemei Janfredi, having paid the sum of 1,500 écus, which it borrowed from a Christian. Renewed anti-Jewish attacks in 1493 eventually led to the general expulsion of the Jews from Marseilles three years after Charles passed away in 1498.[2]
May 14, 1590: On this date the Sumptuary Laws were enacted aimed at the Jews of Casale (Italy). These were laws regulating what Jews may wear, how they may marry, what they may serve at a wedding, and all manner of what might be called social intercourse. These laws were commonplace in Europe and designed to humiliate and punish the Jews in the name of Christ.[3]
May 14, 1637: The Jews of Venice were denied the right to practice law.[4]
May 14, 1782
And on the 14th of May, 1782, three or four days before leaving home, he (Colonel William Crawford) and his wife, for the consideration of natural love and affection, and five shillings, conveyed to his son-in-law, Colonel William Harrison, who accompanied him, 68 acres of land on the Youth River, adjoining the land where the said Harrison then lived. The deed is acknowledged the same day before Providence Mountz, Esq., and appended to it, is a curious memorandum, following the old English feudal feofment: That on the day of the date thereof, full and peaceful possession of the said land being taken & had, by the said Crawford, the same was by him, then and there, in due form, by. turf & twig, delivered to the said Harrison & t4ie? 5 shillings therefore paid. Test: Providence & P.T Mountz, Jr.” t
Brackenridge in speaking of finding the body of Colonel William Harrison, son-in-law of Colonel William Crawford, said that Colonel Harrison had been very active on many occasions in devising means for defense of the frontier. As a citizen and soldier of distinction, he was admired and much respected. He had been a Magistrate, under the jurisdiction of Virginia, and a Delegate to the Assembly of that state. “I know of no man, whose grave sedate manner, prudent conduct, good sense and public- spirit, on all occasions, pleased me more.”[1][5]
The “instructions” afterward sent by Irvine were as follow:
“FORT PITT, May 14, 1782.
“To the officer who will be appointed to command a detachment of volunteer militia, on an expedition against the Indian town at or near Sandusky.
“SIR — When an officer is detached, though he may have general instructions, yet much must depend on his own prudence. On such an expedition as the present, where a variety of unexpected events may take place, I think it would be vain to attempt being particular. In general, however, it is incumbent on me to give such ideas as I think may be of use.
“The object of your command is to destroy with fire and sword (if practicable) the Indian town and settlements at Sandusky, by which we hope to give ease and safety to the inhabitants of this country; but if impracticable, then you will doubtless perform such other services in your power as will, in their consequences, have a tendency to answer this great end.
“Previous to taking up your line of march, it will be highly expedient that all matters respecting rank or command should be well determined and clearly understood, as far at least as first, second and third. This precaution, in case of accident or misfortune, may be of great importance. Indeed, I think whatever rank or grade may be fixed on to have commands, their relative rank should be determined. And as it is indispensably necessary that subordination and discipline should be kept up, the whole ought to understand that, notwithstanding they are volunteers, yet by this tour they are to get credit for it in their tours of militia duty; and that for this and other.[6]
May 14, 1804: The Lewis and Clark expedition leaves St. Louis to explore the new territory acquired by the United States in the Louisiana Purchase.[7]
On May 14, 1836, Texas officially became an independent republic. [8] Gary and Mary Goodlove discovered the name of a Harrison on the official plaque at the Alamo. It is not known if he is a relative. I bet that he is. The Harrison’s never miss a fight.
May 14-15. 1864: Dr. William McKinnon Goodlove (1st cousin, 3 times removed) and the 57th Ohio Volunteer Infantry,Battle of Resaca May 14-15.[9]
Sat. May 14[10], 1864
Started at 7 am marched on leeve of red
River all day camped at 1 oclock at night
May 14, 1864Lt. (?) John A Plum[11] killed in battle near Pesar (sp) GA[12].
John Plum is the compilers 1st cousin four times removed of the wife.
• May 14, 1880: Eugen Gottlieb, born May 14, 1880 in Berlin. Resided at Prenzlauer Berg, Metzer Str. 6; 20, Berlin. Deportation: from Frankfurt a. M. Berlin, September 24/26 1942 to Raasiku. Transport October 3, 1942, Osten, Todesort: Reval, missing[9][13]
•
May 14, 1887: Marta Gottlieb, Geb. Hajek . Born May 14, 1887 in Freiwaldau-Grafenberg. Resided Breslau. Deportation: from Breslau, November 25, 1941, Kowno. Date of death November 29, 1941, Kowno . [14]
May 14, 1896
Oscar Goodlove has been at Anamosa and other neighboring towns all of this week looking for a business location.[15]
May 14, 1901
(Pleasant Prairie) W. H. Goodlove wears his heal tied up, the cause is a severe tooth ache.[16]
• May 14, 1940: The Luftwaffe bombs Rotterdam heavily; the Dutch surrender to the Germans.[17]
May 14, 1941
In the first mass roundup of Jews in Paris, more than 3,700 foreign Jews are arrested when they respond to orderws to report to a gymnasium at 2 rue Japy for police “examination” of their status. Most are of Polish origination (3,430) and the rest are Czech, Austrian, or stateless. They are sent to the Loiret region camps of Pithiviers and Beaune-la-Roland.[18]
May 14, 1948: The United States becomes the first country to recognize Israel as an independent nation.[19]
1948-2001
Antisemitism played a major role in the Jewish exodus from Arab lands. The Jewish population in the Arab Middle East and North Africa has decreased from 900,000 in 1948 to less than 8,000 in 2001.[20]
May 14, 1961: Daniel "Sugar Tramp" GUTLEBEN was born on October 5, 1878 in Colmar,Upper Rhine,Alsace and died on September 5, 1969 in ,Contra Costa,CA at age 90.
Daniel married Miriam Eunice CHURCH on September 19, 1905 in St Louis,Gratiot,Michigan. Miriam was born on September 7, 1876 in Elsie,Clinton, MI and died on May 14, 1961 in ,Contra Costa,CA at age 84. [21]
May 14, 2010
I Get Email!
Hi again, I was away from home for a few days, so I am behind
schedule. I am getting the pages in the mail today. I found your
blogspot. It seems you have some of my paper translated already. It
is true that typically Jews at that time didn't have surnames, per
say, but once you read the whole article it will make sense.
Alice
Alice, I look forward to reading this article. Yes, the translation was from a DNA match with a similar background as yours. It is interesting how much we can learn from the sharing of information. Germany and the surrounding area seem to be a common theme with the DNA matches of 25, 37, and 64 marks. At this level of DNA matching most do not know much about their ancestry before 1800 and do not know they were of Jewish ancestry although some did. Some have a Gottlieb surname derivatives and some do not. That said, most are "big boys" in their field, and are very serious about their discovering their ancestry. I have almost 10,000 names in my family tree, another match has nearly that many, and we both are still trying to connect the dots on this line. I hope to hear more from you, and eventually someone from you or your extended Gutleben family from somewhere in the world might take a DNA test. Perhaps then you will learn about your Gutleben ancestry too.
Jeffery Goodlove
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[1] http://thisdayinjewishhistory.blogspot.com/
[2] http://thisdayinjewishhistory.blogspot.com/
[3] http://thisdayinjewishhistory.blogspot.com/
[4] http://thisdayinjewishhistory.blogspot.com/
[5] [1] Torrence and Allied Families, Robert M. Torrence, pg 328
[6] Washington-Irvine Correspondence by Butterfield, 1882.
[7] On This Day in America by John Wagman.
[8] http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history
[9] William Harrison Goodlove Civil War Diary
[10]There were skirmishes at Wilson’s Landing and Avoyelles (or Marksville) Prairie on the 14th and 15th.
http://www.civilwarhome.com/redrivercampaign.htm
[11] Son of Sally Ann Mckinnon. Ancestors of Forrest Roger Garnett p. 56.3
[12] May 13-16, Resaca, GA 1864;
U.S.A.-600 Killed, 2147 Wounded
C.S.A.-300 Killed, 1500 Wounded
1000 Missing or Captured
Bri. Gen. Wadkins Killed.
• [13] [1] memorial book, victims of the persecution of the Jews under the Nazi dictatorship in Germany 1933-1945. Second and much expanded edition, volume II, GK, edit and herausgegben the Federal Archives, Koblenz, 2006, pg. 1033-1035.
Berlin's memorial book
Judishchen the victims of National Socialism
"Their names like never be obsessed!"
[14] [1] Gedenkbuch, Opfer der Verfolgung der Juden unter der nationalsozialistischen Gewaltherrschaft in Deutschland 1933-1945. 2., wesentlich erweiterte Auflage, Band II G-K, Bearbeitet und herausgegben vom Bundesarchiv, Koblenz, 2006, pg. 1033-1035,.
[15] Winton Goodlove papers.
[16] Winton Goodlove papers.
[17] Encyclopedia of the Holocaust, Israel Gutman, Editor, page 1762.
[18] French Children of the Holocaust, A Memorial, by Serge Klarsfeld, page 18.
[19] On This Day in America by John Wagman.
[20] www.wikipedia.org
[21] Descendents of Elias Gotleben, Email from Alice, May 2010.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment